Messi was named as the world's 2nd best playmaker in 2014 by IFFHS:
RANKINGS 2014
1 – Toni KROOS (Germany / FC Bayern München / Real Madrid CF) 110 points
2 – Lionel MESSI (Argentina / FC Barcelona) 108 points
3 – James RODRIGUEZ (Colombia / AS Monaco / Real Madrid CF) 53 points
4 – Andrès INIESTA (Spain / FC Barcelona) 38 points
5 – Yaya TOURE (Côte d’Ivoire / Manchester City FC) 29 points
6 – Bastian SCHWEINSTEIGER (Germany / FC Bayern München) 28 points
7 – NEYMAR (Brazil / FC Barcelona) and Luka MODRIC (Croatia / Real Madrid CF) 21 points
9 – Eden HAZARD (Belgium / Chelsea FC London) 18 points
10 – Ivan RAKITIC (Croatia / FC Sevilla / FC Barcelona) 5 points
Kroos the best playmaker? I think the fact that he was with Real Madrid which won the CL and Germany which won the WC hugely benefitted him. Otherwise, based on his performances alone (which are by no means bad at all, don't get me wrong), he wouldn't be getting that many points. How many chances has he created?