The reason to bench him for Szczez is latter is far superior keeper. One world class performance won’t change that.
But if Flick decides to keep Pena as first choice for now, he deserved it.
Yeah, I'd easily agree with you even a week ago, but today, I'm not so sure about Szczez being the 'far superior' keeper anymore. I mean, if you compare their careers it's obvious who is better, but as of today, we need to see Szczez play to be able to judge his form and current level of abilities and compare. I've seen a good deal of embarassing blunders and sent offs from him over the years for the clubs and for Poland team, so tbh I wonder which version of Szczez we will see at Barca, the cool world class one or the rash and shaky one.
I do consider him a great (best of all, FREE!) transfer but let's not forget Szczez went out of retirement to play for us, while Pena is only 25 years old which is a baby age for a goalkeeper. He can still improve and hopefully the Bernabeu game can be something he can build on. I guess the jury on Pena's class (whether his Bernabeu display was just a fluke or a taste of things to come) as well as on Szczez's current disposition is still out and we'll see how both of them will do throughout the season.
Anyway we're lucky we can have this conversation. I thought our season was over when TS got injured.