I don't think it's insane. Araujo has his qualities, but so does Garcia. They are pretty much on opposite ends of the CB spectrum
It's a shame Araujo is such a menace for us with the ball at his feet.
The hard facts are any top team looking to play positive and attacking football will struggle very hard with such a big liability on the ball in Araujo.
He is a classic no nonsense center back with little ball playing or carrying ability, and when he is in the side, teams have tried to usher the ball to him and let him stay on it.
This was seen in the PSG game. They were letting him have the ball and laying off him whenever he had it. He had acres of space and time and missed a simple pass that led to him being sent off.
Inigo and Cubarsi in my opinion is the best pairing for us. Garcia vs Araujo is more questionable and Araujo is better but the core point is that with this type of football its clear how hugely we benefit from 2 CBs who can ping the ball around like midfielders.