For me regarding him:
elite skills:
- movement and positional awareness
- first touch
- close ball control
- stamina and energy
good skills:
- short-range passing
- speed and acceleration
- through balls
- defensive contribution
weak points:
- long-range passing, switches of play could be improved especially
- shooting (hard to see how weak it is because he avoids shooting)
Pretty good list tbqh, I agree with most of it. But I think I'm only able to assess strengths, the weaknesses are more to do with simple style or even form (we only saw him play for half a year)
- too afraid to make the final ball
- too often sloppy with the final ball or dribble when he attempts it
- when he dribbles it is too often pre-planned flicks, so he isn't able to switch idea mid-movement quite like Messi or Iniesta
- way too aggressive and sloppy going into tackles
- also a bit too weak, he is too often dispossesed without getting the FK
These are minor things and only reasons he is not the best midfielder in the world already, I think he will develop them with only time and then he will be there. He is much better and more promising than Pedri last year to my eye, and when he plays it makes me forget about Puig being missed. As I know someone will post something about me and Puig, I'll say that at least Puig seems to have a very good shot, and he has some more length to his passes. He has the same problem with decision making, but on the other side as he tries too often, but I think Xavi will focus a lot on both players reaching a good balance there.