Neeraj
Senior Member
Again, I'm curious as to how teams should take penalties through this kind of logic.
So we take whoever is most confident to take the penalties?
I mean, how on earth are you so sure that Suarez is more or less confident that Messi at any given time (it's easy to say this only for this isolated point in time). There's no accurate way to say that. Lets consider your hypothetical situation anyway. Suarez is now the team penalty taker. Suarez stays at this very WC level, but Messi again starts on his insane 2012 (or second half of 14/15) form. You think either of them lack confidence now? How will the penalty situation change now? You can't say that Suarez/Messi is more or less confident if it is already accepted that they are a similar skill level.
The only reason this debate has come along is because Messi was injured. Suarez has only taken 2 penalties for Barcelona. Neymar himself who you say isn't that great of a penalty taker went on quite a long run of scoring his penalties before missing a few.
I mean, if you're looking at a very small number of penalties of a player (that too which he scored), it's going to look as if he's a perfect penalty taker.
Also, I'm not trying to make an argument solely based on statistics, it is you who simply dismiss statistics.
I'm not sure where Messi's playing form on injury even came into the picture. Messi is playing awesome right now; the perceived lack of confidence when he steps up to a penalty isn't really affecting his game or vice versa. And yes, if Suarez become the main pk taker now, and after a season he was struggling and we had to switch to someone else, I would have no problem with that. It isn't a huge deal, just a matter of who trains on them regularly and who's confident.