Well, I wouldn't judge him or any our player just on that match... because Valencia dominated so much that it was imbaressing to watch... we must thank God an Claudio Bravo that they didn't destroy us... they deserved to win by 2 goals at least...
Ok, he is not what he was, you are right... but neither was Alves 'till May, remember? We need those experienced (experience in our system, game, players) players to be able to step in any time... rare are players like hin that can play LB, RB, LM, RM, LW, RW... anything. If he still has any quality left and if he has small wages - I say let's keep him.