Ernesto Valverde - V1

George_Costanza

Active member
That’s just ridiculous lol. While I think a change is needed after that result, to say Tata is better than valverde is quite crazy.

Tata had younger messi, Alves at rb, Neymar, iniesta still in his prime, Busquets still in his prime, and ended trophyless. He also moved away from Barca’s style, just less effectively, so people can’t be hypocritical in the style issue. Also, when lucho and valverde moved away from Barca’s style, it was pragmatic, Barca didn’t have the players to pull off the style because some players were old and slow, guys like rakitic can’t play in a tiki taka system, etc. When Tata moved from the style Barca still had the players to execute it (younger Busquets/Pique, had iniesta in his prime, Alves in his prime, Xavi was still around albeit older)

Valverde has flopped in Europe but you can not deny the work he has done domestically. Barca are consistent in the league with a strong defence.

What are you talking about? We are on paper the best team in Europe this season and we flopped so hard!

Domestically our rivals are in a mess and we have Messi carrying us the whole season even though on paper we are better than Real and ATM. You yourself said it in the Messi's thread.

Tata failed to a team who was much better than us (ATM) on the last day of the league (we drew with ATM). Our team is not as great as you made so, Tata inherited a team that was thrashed by Bayern (7-0), a declined Xavi and injured Messi (was sidelined for quite some time), Neymar first season adjusting, Puyol who played few games the whole season, Song? Alexis Sanchez? Cesc? Dani Alves having an awful season were he became crossing merchant specialist. It's easy to forget how bad were those players for us. Then we lose our main goalkeeper in crucial months to replace him with Pinto for fuck sake.

Tata's football was much better than Valverde and actually influenced Lucho to implement a similar direct philosophy but with better players at his disposal (Neymar, Suarez, Rakitic).

Eventually, Tata was decent enough to step down. He would have won trophies given that we renewed the squad the following season.
 

Hamzah

High Definition Member
Puyol wasn’t even a starter, mascherano was starter. Song wasn’t a starter and Cesc was a decent player, and part of the rotation.

Tata made Alves do crosses with his genius tactics of spamming crosses despite the fact Barca didn’t even have a striker (messi was false nine) and there were to tall players, he did this tactic against Atletico of all teams :lol:. Alves went on to have good seasons the following year with lucho and at juventus in 2017, he wasn’t past it but used ineffectively.

The 7-0 loss was an anomaly, against an all time great Bayern team, our manager was very ill and many players were injured or playing with injury. The team won the league with 100 points. That same team with addition of Neymar flopped in all competitions under Tata. The immediate season after Tata, Barca won the treble.
 
Last edited:

Havesaks

Senior Member
Puyol wasn’t even a starter, mascherano was starter. Song wasn’t a starter and Cesc was a decent player, and part of the rotation.

Tata made Alves do crosses with his genius tactics of spamming crosses despite the fact Barca didn’t even have a striker (messi was false nine) and there were to tall players, he did this tactic against Atletico of all teams :lol:

those crosses were horrific :lol:
 

serghei

Senior Member
Valverde isn't better than Tata Martino. And this doesn't mean Tata Martino is a top manager. Both are about average, and shouldn't even be mentioned in the conversation about a Barcelona worthy manager.
 

Hamzah

High Definition Member
as much as I want a new manager, valverde is at least capable domestically. Tata is capable of nothing, it’s a step backwards not forwards. Tata would be throwing barbecues as the team wins absolutely nothing.

[MENTION=16494]Neymessi[/MENTION] said that Tata was even better than lucho, an absolutely laughable statement.
 

serghei

Senior Member
as much as I want a new manager, valverde is at least capable domestically. Tata is capable of nothing, it’s a step backwards not forwards. Tata would be throwing barbecues as the team wins absolutely nothing.

[MENTION=16494]Neymessi[/MENTION] said that Tata was even better than lucho, an absolutely laughable statement.

So is Tata Martino when Madrid and Atletico are crap. Barca had very weak rivals in the last 2 years on the domestic front because the only comparable team in terms of player quality was a hot mess.
 

Messigician

Senior Member
Why is Rakitic and Coutinho starting? This sends the message of no matter how shit you play you will always start and never be dropped. AWFUL!
 
Wolves > Valverde's Barca at Anfield

Deal with it.

The more I think about it, the more I realize that barcas team is overrated.
Wolves player from any position are able to dribble and create their own chances.
Here all we can do with our average players is pass the ball to Messi.
Time to realize that neither Klopp nor Guardiola would be able to do much with the team we have.
We won la liga b.c every team in it is c.ra.p.
We got lucky by facing Lyon and Manchester United before the semifinals.
The problem is not valverde, although we obviously need a new coach. The problem is playing 30 year olds who haven't won anything important in the last 4 years.
 

serghei

Senior Member
The more I think about it, the more I realize that barcas team is overrated.
Wolves player from any position are able to dribble and create their own chances.
Here all we can do with our average players is pass the ball to Messi.
Time to realize that neither Klopp nor Guardiola would be able to do much with the team we have.
We won la liga b.c every team in it is c.ra.p.
We got lucky by facing Lyon and Manchester United before the semifinals.
The problem is not valverde, although we obviously need a new coach. The problem is playing 30 year olds who haven't won anything important in the last 4 years.

Lol.
 

Luftstalag14

Culé de Celestial Empire
Of course we are overrated. It is pretty much a middle table team plus Messi. When Messi doesn't deliver we are completely crap.

I am really worried about the post-Messi years.
 

Home of Barca Fans

Top