Well each to his own as you say, but I was a Puyol fan from early on, he played with the same intensity back then as he does now. And I don't agree that he was mediocre, after all he was elected best newcomer in la liga 2000-01, and was elected the best rightback in la liga for the 2001-02 season, he was also elected best righback in Europe 2001-02 and 2002-03 by the journalists working for ESM (La Gazzetta dello Sport, Onze Mondial , World Soccer, Kicker etc.). He was also voted into the UEFA Team of the Year 2002.