Just curious but why do you think 2 to be true? We have no way of knowing what he does behind the scenes and during the match he always seems to be shouting, giving instructions and giving his all to motivate them. Behind the scenes there have been reports of him going hard on the team like last season when only 3 or something matches were left in the league, and we ere drawing 0-0 at halftime putting the league in jepordy, he shouted at the players "Wake up we will lose la liga" or something according to sources.
Agree with 1 and 3 though.
You're right we have no idea what he does behind the scenes. But everything on display during our games indicated he can't motivate our team anymore.
He's active on the sidelines but cannot get a response out of the players. Every single game this season that we have been losing at half-time we've never been able to turn around. This is the complete opposite to Lucho's treble winning season when we would simply hammer opposition in the second-half of a game. Lucho received a lot of praise during that season because of how good we were in second-half performances.
If you look at last week's quarter final distance covered stats, Barca covered 10 km less than most other teams. Even Leicester covered more ground than us. It's a sign we aren't fighting anymore. 10 km is near the average at which a player should run during a game, so if we are running 10 km less than other teams with 11 men on the pitch then it's basically like missing an entire player's worth of ground covering, which is massive.
There will always be guys who fight for the badge of the club like Messi, Iniesta, Busi etc. Then we have guys who have performed for the team in the past that look lost and jaded like Saurez, Raki and Alba. Then there are some of the new guys like Arda, Gomes and Denis who barely will even fight for the team.
Lucho's strongest characteristic in his first two seasons here was his ability to motivate the players, which covered his massive tactical flaws, now that he can't do it anymore, his MASSIVE weaknesses are completely exposed.