Mats Hummels

loozy

New member
Given what he said how disappointed he was about the Götze-transfer, he is kind of contradicting himself as he is leaving the club as well, meaning that three of Dortmund's most important players are abandoning the club.

True love? Don't think so.
 

Garrus

New member
Tito prefers thiago silva, Who can blame him, The guy is a monster, But as an investment hummels is better, Younger and cheaper.
 
Tito prefers thiago silva, Who can blame him, The guy is a monster, But as an investment hummels is better, Younger and cheaper.

I wouldn't mind us buying Silva along with someone young like Marquinhos. Hummels definitely has his advantages though, like you said, he's younger and cheaper.

I think Silva + someone young would be the best option, though it'd probably be expensive as hell.
 
Last edited:

Birdy

Senior Member
Hummels is slow as hell.. We need a fast, strong and agile defender next to Pique who can clear dangerous situations. We need a new Puyol. A kind of Kolo Toure of 2000-2007..
Hummels is a far cry from that and will make a terrible partnership with Pique..
 

Galning

Moderator
I love how everybody already knows Piqué and Hummels won't be able to play together. This place is filled with fortune tellers.

Given what he said how disappointed he was about the Götze-transfer, he is kind of contradicting himself as he is leaving the club as well, meaning that three of Dortmund's most important players are abandoning the club.

True love? Don't think so.

Leaving for Barcelona =/= leaving for Bayern.
 

mixer

New member
Barcelona have a deal with Dortmund to sign centre back Mats Hummels (24) for 25M, but Vilanova didn't yet give his approval. [sport]

If this is true, then please Tito - don't be stupid!
 

JamDav1982

Senior Member
He is probably working out exactly who needs to leave to be able to afford Hummels and Neymar.

Plenty of candidates to choose from.
 

Barcaman

Administrator
Staff member
Barcelona have a deal with Dortmund to sign centre back Mats Hummels (24) for 25M, but Vilanova didn't yet give his approval. [sport]

Like most of us here, he also probably thinks that pairing him with Pique is a disaster waiting to happen.
 

Indignado

New member
I would be fine both with Silva and Hummels. Hummels is younger, cheaper and not as injury prone, but Silva is the best defender in the world hands down. I just hope we won't save money on other positions if we get Silva.
 

Home of Barca Fans

Top