If you look at Pep's Barcelona the closest any team got to completely shutting us down in 4 years was Hiddink's Chelsea in 2009 where we didn't even have a shot on target until Iniesta's screamer and were completely dominated. This shows that teams knew the recipe on how to stop us after less than 1 season into Pep's tenure.
Yes but Pep developed our tactics further after his first year. Obviously he failed with having a physical striker, but after that we saw Messi as F9 more regularly. The new equation for opponents then was to rather stop Messi than stop Barca as a whole. Mourinho suceeded with neutralizing Messi by forcing him to move closer and closer to our back 4.
Imo, any team can't keep the rhythm for more than 2-3 seasons. After that, a certain erosion appears in terms of motivation, injuries, fitness levels, which makes the decline happen. It's not so much that the teams catch up and find you out (although it plays a part too of course), it's not like Liverpool play some sort of insanely advanced stuff that other teams are yet to decipher. They press high, get the ball back in deep 'enemy territory' and have fast players who know how to exploit spaces. It's how they scored 3 of the 4 goals against us. As long as they will keep up their hunger and energy levels, and the other big teams like Barca, Madrid, Juventus and Bayern (let's not even mention former great teams like United, Chelsea who have fallen a lot) will continue to show big flaws, Liverpool will probably win (as in they are clear CL favorites).
Tactics aren't rocket science. Sure everybody knows how Liverpool play, everybody knew Pep's tactics too.
I can't remember seeing Liverpool being tactically undone by the opponents so far. Klopp very rarely loses the tactical battle against the opposition coach. Knowing what makes Liverpool win their games is step 1, step 2 is using that knowledge to your advantage, something no team has done, especially at Anfield.
Them riding a huge success wave also adds to their mentality and while they by far aren't unbeatable, they start every game with the mental edge that they are stronger, faster and better than the opponents, doesn't matter if it's Deeney or Messi on the other side.
I'm curious to see how a bad run of 2-3 games would affect them and if/how they'd get back.