Real Madrid (old thread)

Status
Not open for further replies.

Beast

The Observer
That's your version? Tell me, for you, Benzema remains out of the first team?
That's my version of last year classico not next year team
Maybe on paper or a pre-match Spanish TV formation introductions. We couldn't play 4-2-3-1 as Ronaldo was running down the middle and the left flank much more than you'd expect him to and he had to swap positions with someone so that someone couldn't be Marcelo. Also Lass was given the same role of being an RCM with more offensive tasks than Alonso.
Same thing with April El Clasico, 4-3-3 with (from the right) Gago-Xabi-Marcelo and CR-Higuain-VdV where CR and the Dutch are slightly behind Gonzalo with different tasks to fulfil.

My version:
-----------------Defense---------------------
--------Lass----Xabi-------Marcelo---------
CR-------Higuain-------Kaka

You could also visualise it 4-3-2-1, but 4-3-3 makes much more sense. This season it is likely to change to 4-2-3-1, but if so then we need a box-to-box mid with good defensive skills to avoid having a gap between DMs and AMs which is why Khedira is coming (that gap was a reason why we got overwhelmed in midfield in El Clasicos).
I beg to differ
that was the pre-match preview of all Spanish press , Manuel changed his formation several times , started with 4-2-2-2 dropped it after the defeats in the CL and Copa picked 4-2-3-1 through out the period of the first classico till early January when he switched to 4-3-3
the 4-3-3 barely makes sense when you have Marcelo playing as a Left winger most of the time , i had a graphic display even from Marca but sadly the old clasico threads were deleted
the fact is Kaka sucked ass when he played in the 4-3-3 so hard it was a blessing when he was out and VDV played instead as he connected the forward line with the midfield .
there is reason why the Spanish Real Madrid forum and fans opinion wanted Kaka out of the team
 

diegomessi

Anxiously waiting for the next match
canales has been dreadful today, I dont see how he will get into madrid's first team... should be loaned imo
 

Moe

powered by;
I dont think they bought him to get into the first team this year. he's one for the future and if anything I agree with you that they should loan him out.
 

diegomessi

Anxiously waiting for the next match
I dont think they bought him to get into the first team this year. he's one for the future and if anything I agree with you that they should loan him out.

by 1st team i meant the 22 man roster not the youth team.. i just really think he needs playing time i think sense madrid have enough players another year at racing would do him good.. not having a dig as obviosuly he has potential and talent but just watched him in the u19 and was very dissapointed bad game perhaps
 

Beast

The Observer
Doesn't mean a lot really Benj , last summer Bojan was crap in the youth tourny and he was amazing in the run for the title , on the other hand Asenjo was great and Spain best player and was a douche with Atletico
 

diegomessi

Anxiously waiting for the next match
yea thats true you know i just hate to see a young player that coild help spain alot not get to develop bc of a premature move to a loaded squad
 

El Gato

Villarato!
Beast
If you're talking 4-2-3-1 where is Granero's place in that lineup when Kaka was also in the first 11 ? He didn't play left wing instead of Marcelo, in fact, he hardly played as a winger at all last season.
 

Aryagorn

Improvin' Perfection!!
I guess deep lying if you are to win a game, need to score goals, etc... the attacking role, play in hole if you were to defend your lead
 

Beast

The Observer
Beast
If you're talking 4-2-3-1 where is Granero's place in that lineup when Kaka was also in the first 11 ? He didn't play left wing instead of Marcelo, in fact, he hardly played as a winger at all last season.

Jesus man , where you really watching Real last season ?
one on Manuel main weak point was the lack of stability in his formation
4-2-2-2 with CR-Kaka behind the two striker early in the season, 4-2-3-1 from mid november onwards till January than 4-3-3 till the end mixed with 4-3-1-2 in the last series of games !?
Granero played in the 4-3-3 pretty evident in the game vs Deportivo in la Coruna , before that he played as a sub for the AM in 4-2-2-2 or if Manuel wanted to change the double pivots with a more attacking role but his games started more with Depor in which he scored the first goal in them
Marcelo played as a LCM for one game only all season due to injuries
 

El Gato

Villarato!
Chill out dude. Get your head together.
You're sort of right because Pellegrini had to change formations due to injuries, suspensions etc. etc. but now then, I simply don't see how 4-2-3-1 can work out against any of the teams who boss the midfield eg. Barca. Mourinho will probably adjust the formation to the players and to Ronaldo (as he mentioned in last interview), but for this moment I'm full of doubts with regards current team.
It takes patience. :]
 
Last edited:

Barcafan 2304

New member
To be fair, i dont think Real are expecting Canales to be a superstar this season. Looking at him to continue his progression and be part of their future plans
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Home of Barca Fans

Top