Odd comparison . One newbie is not a veteran and proven winner. What stunned me is aston villa actually attacked city the whole match ! They actually dominated that squad of city coached by pep !
I hear you. And both are at different stages in their managerial career- Xavi starting and Emery consolidated.
We could say that Emery never got fully trusted in a top tier project as of yet (PSG and Arsenal) and that's why he failed in those stints.
But then again, seeing a coach in Emery with those "failures" at the top do so well in England, may support that a coach like Xavi if funded and supported could also do well there.
I guess that was my point.
About Emery, I'm old enough to remember when he made his breakthrough at Almeria. And how to bridge the gap in talent, he made them innovate their set pieces to increase their set piece success rate. He found a scenario that he could give his team an advantage.
In a way, it shows his guile and intelligent as a manager, but in another, it shows at heart how he has always harvested the underdog mentality and how he thrives more working in that environment.