Xavi by a mile. They both suck at shooting but I see Xavi take his chances more often. Iniesta is predetermined to pass so even if he does find space/angles to score, it hardly matters at that point because it's not what he's looking for.
When Andres does score it's mostly, as you can see from replays, because he is looking to score - not pass. Check Chelski goal he is winding up before the ball even gets to him. It's like he has a sensor that turns on that says, "Ok, Andres it's time to score a goal!" Turning on that sensor more often might be the trick.
Concur
If Xavi finds himself in a good position OUTSIDE the box with no option to pass he's more liekly to shoot as oppose to penetrate by dribbling like Iniesta.
Xavi has better long range shooting and most of his goals 've come from them. While he can dribble in to the box and has done so on a few occasions hes more confident from long distance. But then he'd also like to maintain his position. So I do agree on the first part.
However when Xavi recieves the ball inside the box he always panics, twist and turn until hes able to pass it. While Andres will try his luck more often than not.
Not this. I associate it more with Iniesta. Xavi inside the box will take his chance 9/10 times. Hes more confident in front of goal as opposed to casper who tends to freeze and looks for a pass if his sees an option regardless of whether it being the right choice or not. Not sure if this can be attributed to bad decision making or mere diffidence on his part. For now i can remember Mestalla 08/09 and the WC finals where he showed hesitancy in good positions. Now i dont recall Xavi doing it. any instance you can produce? And if wht you're saying is true, seeing Iniesta finds himself in more goal scoring position than Xavi, then the former should've been more productive than Xavi which is not the case. (Xavi does take setpieces but thats minimal)
#4,7,9 didn't see much twisting and turning looking for an option and he had some. Now if tht was Iniesta for #4 he would 've tried passing to Villa
I do however agree on Xavi using more power & accuracy in his shots in open play while Iniesta with more emphasis on technique and placement. Although tht Madrid one was just great technique from the man.