Very interesting article. Is the author really legit? If so, that's some new interesting information on the case.
I also liked Liverpool's statement, but I believe they should have appealed, mostly for moral reasons. The consequences of this decision for football as a whole will be disastrous. I understand why they gave up the case, but I wish they hadn't.
This decision and the reactions to it have only contributed to the trivialization of racism. I don't think the FA and some of the posters on here (and other places) realize how serious a matter racism is. It seems like some football fans now regard racism as a "card" to be played, a "weapon" to see the player they don't like punished. Accepting that someone can be punished by racism with no evidence is pretty much accepting that racism is as serious as your common civil offense.
Racism is a hate crime, one of the biggest plagues of the current society (and in football as well) and one that unfortunately only seems to be growing. And yet it seems like people don't care about that at all.
This is what saddens me the most about this case. This is not a decision that will contribute to eliminate racism, it's a decision that will encourage racism. More specifically, it's a decision that trivializes racism; basically, any player can accuse a fellow player of racism and get him banned even with no evidence at all.
And the worst part is of course that most fans seem to comply with this trivialization, as seen for instance in some posts in this thread, agreeing with the decision because the player they don't like has been punished or disagreeing with it just because their team's player has been punished. I don't see how we can eradicate racism in football (and society of course) while people keep having this attitude. This all process only shows huge disrespect for all those who are indeed daily victims of racial abuse, by basically making a mockery of the suffering they go through.
This must be a new low for football: racism turned into a mere weapon to get rival players suspended.
Good post.
This incident has just enforced my belief that people are very easily manipulated. Throw an emotive issue like racism out there and people immediately turn into rabid animals incapable of critical thinking.
Being at the end of racist abuse is a terrible thing and i have enough experiences of that with me being of mixed race. I hold racists with the utmost disgust which is why i think if anyone is going to be labelled a racist there should be no if's or buts about it. Even if there is 95% evidence to suggest that they are racist, only 100% should do.
This Suarez case really depresses me and at the same it makes me furious thinking that three middle aged, white men who have no real life experiences on racism are holding themselves to be the judge, jury and executor of such a subject and on the balance of probabilities too. Having newspapers like the Daily Mail, Express, Telegraph, Times , newspapers that constantly display xenophobic tendencies, sitting on their high horses telling people like myself how i should feel about racism or what i should consider racist. And it just saddens me that there are people who no doubt are well intentioned, falling for such a scam.
Suarez a mixed race man was FA's scapegoat for their fight against racism and the scapegoat that will prevent real justice in the case of Terry, a pure white, England captain (not a dirty south american) being done. Because you see, everyone's appetite is now satisfied.
As for Liverpool, i can understand they were stuck in between a rock and a hard wall but they should have done the right thing. In the end they chose the easiest way out. Really feel let down with the club. Shankly would never have taken such a stance.