9 - Robert Lewandowski

Status
Not open for further replies.

Respekt_III

Anti-everything
I know they are using this card in their argument about MAne's valuation.

But it's a totally unfounded claim:
- Mane is a forward, and forwards always cost more than midfielders
- Thiago was same age then as MAne is now
- Covid affected prices in 2020 and they didn't give them a bargain as they say, but simply accepted the market at the time of covid with significant deflation on all assets including players
- this line of 'giving favors' to 'get favors' in return is a huge ton of BS. No such conversations ever took place.
They were worried they are losing Thiago for free, they even made a public statement about it. Liverpool decided to offer something that they would take in fear of losing him for free

First statement is obviously not factual. That's more to due to the way the statement is made more than the intended meaning though so whatever.

Midfielders can generally play for much longer and at higher levels than pacey attackers that heavily rely on their physical attributes no? So having said that aren't older Midfielders worth more than older attackers generally speaking?

Bayern wanted more than the 20m they got for thiago in fact they wanted at least 50% more.

Bayern have allowed players to run down their contracts on multiple occasions so it's not unreasonable to beleive they they had taken the players wishes into consideration when accepting a much lower offer or had some sort of Informal agreement of a sort. Something you claim as fact although neither of us are privy to that information, we may only speculate. Historical transfers surrounding bayern seem to indicate that this unofficial understanding could very well have been discussed or expected but not legally binding (no one was saying it was anyway). So claiming that none of these conversations took place is conjecture no?

Significant covid depreciation would of potentially been true for the 19/20 season but he was bought in the 20/21 season where most footballing asset valuations had recovered.

Liverpool has done the same if not worse to other clubs regarding transferring lowballing etc yet the language used to describe their practise is one of positivity compared to the language used to describe bayern from posters like yourself.

Edit: don't really care about it either way just find it amusing. The duality of Liverpool stans lol
 
Last edited:

topt

Senior Member
I know they are using this card in their argument about MAne's valuation.

But it's a totally unfounded claim:
- Mane is a forward, and forwards always cost more than midfielders
- Thiago was same age then as MAne is now
- Covid affected prices in 2020 and they didn't give them a bargain as they say, but simply accepted the market at the time of covid with significant deflation on all assets including players
- this line of 'giving favors' to 'get favors' in return is a huge ton of BS. No such conversations ever took place.
They were worried they are losing Thiago for free, they even made a public statement about it. Liverpool decided to offer something that they would take in fear of losing him for free

not true, Klopp turned his head
from what I read a new offer is coming from Barca, close to 50 I hope
 
Last edited:

Luftstalag14

Culé de Celestial Empire
not true, Klopp turned his head
from what I read a new offer is coming from Barca, close to 50 I hope

I hope Tebas shoots us down so we can't sign him at all.

No money for Bayern, not a single penny.

Perhaps we should take a page from Bayern's playbook, only pay a variable of 20m if he gets a hattrick of Ballon' dors.
 

topt

Senior Member
I hope Tebas shoots us down so we can't sign him at all.

No money for Bayern, not a single penny.

Perhaps we should take a page from Bayern's playbook, only pay a variable of 20m if he gets a hattrick of Ballon' dors.

well, I wouldnt be shocked if we made a deal and Bayern doesnt get a single penny; you still owe us some money for Vidal
 

Luftstalag14

Culé de Celestial Empire
well, I wouldnt be shocked if we made a deal and Bayern doesnt get a single penny; you still owe us some money for Vidal

We might, but that doesn’t mean we should be paying you anything, certainly not on your crazy terms.

Seriously, with all the bravado talks from your big wigs, you should just stick it to Lewandowski and refuse to sell him.
 

topt

Senior Member
We might, but that doesn’t mean we should be paying you anything, certainly not on your crazy terms.

Seriously, with all the bravado talks from your big wigs, you should just stick it to Lewandowski and refuse to sell him.

:) no no, we have to respect players wishes and him wanting to go to his dream club Real ups sorry Barca
 

Luftstalag14

Culé de Celestial Empire
:) no no, we have to respect players wishes and him wanting to go to his dream club Real ups sorry Barca

For your silly pride, just keep him. Otherwise, Hainer, Kahn and Brazzo prove that they are just a bunch of bozos, after numerous times of insisting he will fulfill his contract.
 

Catta

Senior Member
The salt from the Bayern fan :lol:

Barca at their lowest in 20 years, while Bayern is at their highest, and still their best player wants to leave them for this Barca. They are acting like QSG, trying to get one over in the transfer market because their little pride got hurt.
 

topt

Senior Member
The salt from the Bayern fan :lol:

Barca at their lowest in 20 years, while Bayern is at their highest, and still their best player wants to leave them for this Barca. They are acting like QSG, trying to get one over in the transfer market because their little pride got hurt.

Salt ? unloading a 34 year old forward on massive wages that most players dont like; yeah lets call it salt :)
If he was really the reason for poor performances by Sane since new year I would ship him out for free
 
Last edited:

Temptation

Well-known member
Salt ? unloading a 34 year old forward on massive wages that most players dont like; yeah lets call it salt :)
If he was really the reason for poor performances by Sane since new year I would ship him out for free

Yeah RL9, the only consistent and by far the best Bayern player for ages is responsible for the inconsistent, precious, lil German darling's dip in form. :lol:

You should probably ship him out for free since ypu lot are "one big happy family" unlike the other demonic big clubs....:lol:
 

topt

Senior Member
Yeah RL9, the only consistent and by far the best Bayern player for ages is responsible for the inconsistent, precious, lil German darling's dip in form. :lol:

You should probably ship him out for free since ypu lot are "one big happy family" unlike the other demonic big clubs....:lol:

lets just say I am extremely happy with Mane for Lewa swap
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Home of Barca Fans

Top