I disagree. Arthur has proven much more (Copa libertadores, Copa America, starter for Brazil, more gamesense etc), of course people get carried away, but hes pretty much the best midfield talent we had since Thiago (not counting Frenkie).
Arthur
- Thread starter Jair Ventura
- Start date
I disagree. Arthur has proven much more (Copa libertadores, Copa America, starter for Brazil, more gamesense etc), of course people get carried away, but hes pretty much the best midfield talent we had since Thiago (not counting Frenkie).
serghei
Senior Member
And you say this knowing the fact that Barcelona is known worldwide as being a possession based team?
And you basically admit Arthur is the best at this and still you and a bunch of other say he is shit?Worst in professionalism
What the fuck. And you have proof of this because he was riding a scooter. .
Last edited:
CatalinR10
Senior Member
so if FDJ or God forbid Messi gets injured next year and plays only half of it , he's not a top player anymore because of his injury , regardless of how good he was in the period he actually played. Gotcha dawg.
It was already proven with facts by high quality Mensa iq tests that i'm extremely inteligent so NT with that dawg.
And honestly i'd rather be an <80iq guy rather than some guy who logs in just to hate on high quality players , must be miserable SMH.
KingLeo10
Senior Member
Of course Arthur is a top player.
By the logic of some, we should have sold a young Messi because he was injury prone.
Nazario1985
Senior Member
Of course Arthur is a top player.
By top player i mean top player for this Club don't give a shit what he's done for Grimeao
Oh you want to play the market value card knowing that this board can boost a cockroach to 100m+ market value ?
He IS a good player, no question or doubt about that.
But until he get his shit together he IS useless for THIS club !!!
Nobody is talking about selling him or that shit we can read in some posts !!! it's just if by the same logic you apply to Dembélé (Talent / no problem if injured / market value) Dembélé is a Top 3 player !!
Nazario1985
Senior Member
Why not count FDJ ? just to slip the BEST while the rest of the mid players are all past their primes and the only guy who should be compared to him is FDJ ?
Last edited:
Vilarrubi
New member
CatalinR10
Senior Member
Nazario1985
Senior Member
Put the context of the reply otherwise you're just barking
And it changes nothing about those saying he is fine FW !!
With 9 ASSISTS - 4 goals in his WHOLE career including Grimeo AND Brazil NT !!
Last edited:
Nazario1985
Senior Member
I thought he will be back in January !! with Semedo also out !!! f***
https://www.football-espana.net/82519/barcelona-arthur-melo-out-month-january
https://www.football-espana.net/82519/barcelona-arthur-melo-out-month-january
JohnN
Senior Member
He put the reply into context by quoting two contradicting things you say. Firstly you use stats from all his teams and then you say you only care about what he does here at Barca. He has improved this year offensively. He has improved physically. He was much faster and agile. The only problem is the pubis pain thing. But, for the time he was fit he did really well. Let's hope he is fit again so we can evaluate what he brings to the team.
All this talk about out of field problems is an excuse to demote Arthur. Let's put it this way. When healthy, he is our second best midfielder overall. I don't know if he fits the team. I don't know if he can work together with Fdj. But purely skilwise he is our second best option.
All this talk about out of field problems is an excuse to demote Arthur. Let's put it this way. When healthy, he is our second best midfielder overall. I don't know if he fits the team. I don't know if he can work together with Fdj. But purely skilwise he is our second best option.
Nazario1985
Senior Member
The stats was a reply for him being a WC player overall
The fact i don't care what he's done at Grimeo have nothing to do with that, it's like saying Coutinho is a WC player but WTF he achieved at Barça ?
I'm not putting down Arthur & i double down on him for the futur but sucking his d**** and saying he is already WC because he's done better offensively than last season which was HORRIBLE !! it's like improving from zero to one and say wow that's amazing.
He is a beast in other areas but need to offer something upfront, and as you said he has improved.
I put the stat to show how a player he is, and HE is not offensive YET
People who want to extrapolate my comment to please their fucking mind, don't give a shit about them they even start talking market value lol !!! Dembélé cough !!!
Point is he is good needs to improve Stamina/offense/stop stupid injuries !!
Home of Barca Fans
