Maradona37
Well-known member
Very good post but especially the bold. Players have peaks and troughs and circumstances matter greatly. Players from the big western European nations for example will always have great advantages in terms of facilities, coming through their home league etc. Players from Eastern Europe, Scandinavia and other continents typically have a less easy career trajectory and have to massively uproot sticks etc.The thing with Dovbyk shows how important patience is especially with attackers. His first good season was at 24 years old in Ukraine and only moved to a top5 league at 26 years old. He flopped in Denmark at 23.
Then he moves to Spain at 26 and wins LaLiga golden boot in his first season here which is an award that far more reputable players have never won.
Really shows you how development is not linear and personal context is important when considering players. Sometimes players have the talent but they're just waiting for it to click or to resolve certain flaws they have.
I'm sure if we signed Dovbyk the fans would complain massively about signing a player from Ukraine, flopped in Denmark etc. Of course, not blaming the club for him specifically, but just an example that you could apply to other players like Roque when being overly critical and not being patient with players development curves and progression.
I know guys like Vini have done well for example, but imagine how difficult it must be to leave Brazil for Europe aged 18. Compare that to Saka who came through the academy of his local club in the most popular league in the world and never had to move to another city or anything. Saka will have made sacrifices too but still. That's just one example but it shows how conditions are easier for some players. This might be why (for example) someone like Salah (despite being good) didn't actually hit his top level until he was 25 - he had a different upbringing. Had he been English or French and come through their youth systems he'd likely have been top as a teenager.