I wouldn't be sad if we sell Pique and get Benatia to replace him. However, I'd rather prefer Hummels as he is younger and more proven. But since Hummels is not available this summer, the board should give Pique a final warning and bench him in a few big games now that we have 4 CBs. If he still doesn't improve then use him to negotiate with Klopp for Hummels. Klopp is a no BS guy who can get Pique to work hard, especially that he won't have any influence in BVB. Wishful thinking I know ! On second thought, Lucho is known to be a tough guy as well and if he is truly given the control to operate the team however he wants, I will be shocked if Pique doesn't improve - at least his attitude if not his form.