We outplayed Real Madrid. It was basically game over and won already at camp nou before Valdes did the biggest derp mistake ever and gave them a free goal. Then we lost 1-2 away vs real away with 10 men and if I remember correctly we had at least 2 really good chances to make it 2-2, the ball from Masch to Pedro and some other.
Tito didn't fail winning the Super Cup, if any blame is to be put on anyone it is Valdes or how the whole team played the first 25 minutes at Bernabeu which is probably the worst 25 minutes I've ever seen barcelona play.
But if we won, it would be Tito's work, right? I remember both games very well. And how can you say we outplayed Madrid? Yes, we had a few good chances we didn't convert, but also, in the first half of the second game, we could have easily conceded at least 5-6 goals. It was because of pure luck and El Pipita's shooting that we did not. Besides, it doesn't matter why we lost or how we lost. We lost. End of story. That's one trophy that could have been on our shelf, but instead it's in Madrid. Therefore, 0/1. Nothing more to it. And you can count who made how many mistakes, but eventually it comes down to the coach, he is the one with the most authority and responsibility, whether we're talking about winning or losing. It's not all about who's the better team and who has better tactics, we all know luck has a lot to do with it as well, but in 10 years time, nobody will talk about what the game was like, they'll talk about who the trophy went to.