Is it a coincedence that all 3 players you mentioned were a flop in England? Where they waste money and don't think about their transfers? Everyone in Holland would have said that Depay needed an extra step before going to United and that Janssen had a hot season. Overcourse AZ is going to accept a retarded offer of 25m for Janssen. PSV was interested and wanted to go as far as 8-10m. English clubs create their own flops, the Eredivisie is not to blame for it.
Wijnaldum needed a year to acclimatise in England, after that he became a starter for Liverpool. What about Suarez? He was a big hit in Liverpool after coming from Ajax. And there are more examples of players from the Eredivisie who don't need an extra step before going to a bigger competition.
By the way, Klaassen is doing very very well in de Bundesliga now, at a similar club to Everton.
It's quite a biased statement to make. It comes down to bad/lazy scouting, mainly by English clubs.
Don’t agree that Suárez overperformed. He was a machine at Ajax.I think there are many factors in play with Eredivisie players.
- Suarez: overperformed. He was great at Ajax but far from a generational talent. There were stong doubts he would make in PL
- Wijnaldum: overperformed big time. He was a very decent player at PSV. Newcastle was the perfect stepping stone for him but he has the right mentality and developed A LOT in PL. That guy must be so eager to learn and invest himself. Amazing
- Klaassen: underperformed. Was the key player a very mediocre Ajax that was winning the Dutch league because of the low perfomance of other clubs as well. Everton seemed the PERFECT choice. Everybody here agreed that he would pbb stay there for 2 years and then make an attempt at a bigger club. Boy, were we wrong...
- Siem de Jong: Bad luck with injuries but also clearly not PL material. This was also kinda surprising because he was rated quite high. Newcastle seemed a save pick from his side
- Depay: great player. ManU was too big. He is an asshole with a poor mentality. Could be a case of bad scouting? Great at Lyon now
- Janssen: poor scouting. Teared up the Eredivie for a half a year only. Was no way near the Spurs level. Also coming directly from a small NL club
- Eriksen: he was a generational talent and is showing it
Lets not forget players like Verthongen, Alderwereld, Sanchez,
I don't think so. Although I agree on you on the bad scouting but the aforementioned players fell beyond short of the level required for the league, let alone their respective teams.
Klaassen for instance had 4 different managers not even wanting him on the bench, including the one who signed him. Memphis had zero work-rate and after something like 40 league games scored 1 goal and had zero assists as a forward. Janssen wasn't even good enough for the Turkish league either, got benched all season long there for a past-it Soldado and then sent back to England where Pochettino reckons he's not even good enough to warrant a squad number.
As for Klaassen doing well in Germany, Werder Bremen fans tend to say he's a decent squad player who goes through his ups and downs. The difference is this is a league that's been declining of late and nowhere near as tough as the Premier League.
Suarez was a different story, he was always a mercurial, generational talent, plus Eredivisie was much better then. Wijnaldum did well because his level is much higher than the other 3, you could see right away he belonged at this level. Eriksen not only likewise, but even more so.
Don’t agree that Suárez overperformed. He was a machine at Ajax.
Don’t agree that Suárez overperformed. He was a machine at Ajax.
Its not that simple, its not like we want to pay this amount of money for players, the clubs just won't sell for less and if we don't pay, someone else will, which isn't an option since we must stay n1 club with the most superstars.
Amigo, you want a sub-par player like Rabiot to play for Barca. Umh...
No, clubs know we have incompetent morons running the club (seeing our transfer history) and charge us a premium accordingly. Those players wont necessarily sell for those prices because most clubs wont be stupid enough to pay that much for them. We massively exceeded anything PSG offered according to reports (and we had the player wanting to play with us on top of that)..
De Jong is not a superstar he's far from it so that point is moot, purchasing younger players with potential is meant to be cheaper because its riskier... yet sometimes it costs more then established players... I dont see an x-factor in this guy like dembele, i think it won't ever be as bad as the Coutinho situation because he fits our system and can play in a position we require reinforcement in.
Its easy to call them idiots but they are educated people running a business, and the reports that we "exceeded" PSG offers are a meme, how in the world some journos know the numbers that have been discussed.
Its very very rare that a superstar that age and from a league like that would not be an attacker, and he still is climbing very fast into the superstar status being a midfielder in ajax. And he obviously is more than just a "prospect" or unproven.
First of all running a football club isn't like running a business, Secondly we are at extreme risk with our current financial situation. Barto and Co would never take the risks they are taking or spending the amount they are spending if it was their money.
I know plenty of 'educated' people, being 'educated' means fuck all to me as you can be educated yet still be a moron/stupid.