Predicted them to be poor again at the start of the season, but of course the likes of JamDav deluded himself with his pathetic little sniggers on my posts.
It was so obvious to anyone with sense that they're going nowhere. I could write an essay on how bad they are. A couple of people (Horatio being the other) laughed when I said the issues were still apparent against Fulham, but the last two games have proved it.
These five signings they have made represent AT BEST a slight improvement too. I really don't rate De Ligt, Mazraoui, Zirzkee, Yoro looks a talent but is young and currently injured. Ugarte will be poor for them too, I guarantee it - he's nothing like what they need in defensive midfield. They needed a playmaker - instead they have a clown who flies into tackles, is awful when pressed and can't pass water. If they're pinning their hopes on him and the other players their previous clubs didn't want anymore then they have big problems.
There's two issues for them on the park - the first is the players are nowhere near as good as their fans think, and their fans clearly have the attitude that someone who plays for Man United is automatically better than someone who plays for a 'small club' like Brighton (for the record I would take Mitoma and Joao Pedro over every single attacker Man United have(. it's an archaic way of thinking 'we are a bigger club so we automatically have better players'. No, they are just more hyped by the media.
The second problem they have is that Ten Hag is an absolute moron. I said in summer 2023 that he wouldn't be United coach when 2025 rolls in, and I stand by that. If he is United coact at New Year then this new management structure will clearly be incompetent (that's another thing they were getting giddy about, I am pretty sure this new management structure will prove to be incompetent too, just because they aren't the Glazers doesn't make them any good).
It must be great for their clown fans when they are the best team in July when no football is being played, or when they 'win the transfer window' before any of these players have even kicked a ball for them. They have made the same mistake repeatedly over the years but never ever learn.
The overall problem they have though is that the club is rotten to its core. They have so much arrogance from top to bottom, think the club is special with meaningless platitudes like 'This is Manchester United', as if comments like that will help them improve. If anything the first step to them actually getting better is showing some humility and dropping the arrogance. They've been a nothing club for their entire history other than at two points - under Busby and under Ferguson. This is simply them reverting to the mean.
Unfortunately most forum dwellers ar under 40 and think football started in 1992 so have this misguided impression (due to the 90s) that United are a historically successful club. They aren't. Their European record is embarrassing and 2/3 of their league titles were won under Ferguson.
I could do on but the club is simply doomed, and destined to fail. The rot is too deep. They're still trying to play football like a very basic counter-attack from the 90s and early 2000s. That worked in the PL then, but will never ever work now in the era of greater tactical cohesion.
Their fans are still desperate and clinging to false hope too - I have saw a few of them cling to the fact they had a better xG than Liverpool yesterday, had as many shots, more possession. FFS, about xG - it's clearly only a worthy tool when used over a prolonged period, not in one-off games. And any 'xG model' that says Liverpool should have scored fewer than two goals yesterday is completely broken - Diaz's second goal is a great finish from a low likelihood chance, fair enough, but his first is a free header into an empty net from 5 yards FFS!. Yet apparently he as an individual had an xG of 0.31 yesterday? How?! The only way I can see that not being a sitter is because Szobo was in his way putting him off, but even with that, it would have been criminal had Diaz missed that. Yet I assume xG gives it about 0.2 likelihood of being scored? Bollocks. Then there's Szobo not shooting into an open net, Salah (one of the best players in the world) with a free shot on goal where Onana's positioning was horrendous, and a few other things. Anyone who thinks that xG was an accurate predictor of yesterday's game must be very misguided.
As for the shots and more possession - the latter comes from United generally passing it about at the back. The former is obvious - United got nowhere near Liverpool's goal really until Liverpool had scored and then were 2-0 and 3-0 up. Liverpool had taken their foot off the gas and were toying with United by then.
This is the weakness of stats, especially in football - people throw them about minus CONTEXT. Qualitative data is just as important if not more so than quantitative. Stats are often misused or abused by people, which is why those with no understanding of how to analyse them think yesterday was 'a close game', or that Brighton weren't better than United last week.
Ultimately United are still a shambles and going nowhere. Ten Hag is an absolute clown but it goes far deeper than him - the club is rotten to its core. Like I have been saying for years, it could be decades before they challenge again. Their fans think it will take a few transfer windows - I think they're in for a very rude awakening. And these new players they've very excited about? They'll be the deadwood they are desperate to get rid of in 3 seasons. Then the cycle will repeat.