KingLeo10
Senior Member
I'm not sure you can just reduce the Ferguson era United to the 98/99 treble to be fair, the whole Ferguson era rivals pretty much any clubs successful period. Plus they have had the Matt Busby era too in the late 60's.
13 league titles
5 FA Cups
4 league cups
2 Champions leagues and 2 runners up
1 Cup winners cup ( still miss that competition)
SAF has a reign of 26 years. In the similar ~ 26 years since Johan Cruyff took over, Barca had:
13 La Liga
5 CLs and 1 runner up
6 Copa Del Rey
10 League Cups
Agree that United is comparable/no slouches, but the question is pertaining to the tendency of United fans and PL fans' tendency to claim United are THE biggest club. I don't think you can make a solid argument for them being bigger than RM (clear cut)/ Barca (sizable gap but still could be argued)/ Bayern (sizable gap but still could be argued). Milan gets shortchanged in these discussions but up until 2007ish, you could make a case for them being the top dog with RM. Pool is also underrated and I feel on equal footing to United historically.
But I'm also not living in the UK, so I acknowledge the perceptions there are different and can definitely see the aura of United overshadowing other clubs if one grew up in UK during 90s and 00s.