Except that defence bar Vidic is absolutely shit.
in what way was Evans shit? i love it how you try to come across as if you have no bias, when in reality your the same as any liverpool fan i've ever encountered on a forum. While i wouldnt agree he's better than Agger, hes a very good CB now. Good composure and bringing the ball out added to that.
Rafael has work to do, but would get in ahead of the majority of Full backs in the league, bar Walker and Richards/Zabaleta.
Evra is declining, but if the Rumours of Baines etc are true he may be replaced or at least have competition, still far from shit.
and i really hope your not including De Gea in the 'shit'? that would be ridiculous.