Female volleyball players are massively overrated in the looks department because of their fit bodies and sun kissed tans. They nearly always let you down facially. Especially if you are unfortunate enough to see a photo of them without make up on and you realise that, damn she looks like her father.
In fact that could be said of most pretty girls generally. Which is why most of them will do their best not to let you see them bare faced. Its very difficult to get excited by women when you realise that without make up and long hair, they are very boyish looking.
Most of these girls guys go crazy for online, you would not give a second look if you got to see them first thing in the morning, au naturale. I used to be under the same delusion until I was lucky enough to date a few and was massively underwhelmed.
It is what it is.