Transfers and Rumours - old thread

B

beautifulgame

Guest
Barca had four reliable centre halves in Puyol, Pique, Abidal and Marquez. One has left, one has regressed a bit and two are too fragile to rely on due to a combination of age, injury and illness. A makeshift midfield player in Mascherano has done an 'emergency' job for two seasons now.

It's the weakest area of the squad that Messi's freakish number of goals and assists have carried all season. Unless Bartra - or another B player - is going to be used as a regular member of the squad next season then two centre backs are needed. Pique, Puyol and two others.

this!

and if pique doesn't give enough of a f*** to get his career back on track then he can be sold as far as I'm concerned.
 

0n0mat0p0eia

New member
The question is when DOES Pique focus? I'd say we need 2 because Puyol can't play forever and aside from him we have 3 CB's... it's not out of the question to buy one experienced and versatile defender now who can help stabilize the defense, and one for the future to build a defensive system around...

Amorebieta - Free in the summer. Would give the team experience, height and some bite (okay, hes prone to the odd red card)
Martinez - a young, powerful CB that would be in our team for years to come.

Getting Amorbieta free and Martinez for a reasonable fee would leave more than enough money for us to buy a world class 'Keeper (Ter Stegen).

Sadly, i suspect that we will buy Neymar and will tilt at windmills for Hummels - who we wont get - and end up with the same situation for next season.
 
Y

Youngie

Guest
Amorebieta - Free in the summer. Would give the team experience, height and some bite (okay, hes prone to the odd red card)
Martinez - a young, powerful CB that would be in our team for years to come.

Getting Amorbieta free and Martinez for a reasonable fee would leave more than enough money for us to buy a world class 'Keeper (Ter Stegen)

Isn't that what I said a few pages back? :D (pg 61)

It makes sense. Amorbieta may be "prone to the odd red card" but so are Pique & Masch. Barça need another "beast" in defense to scare the crap out of the opposition because right now our defense is a joke...

Hope you're listening Tito & co.: Fernando Amorebieta & Iñigo Martínez in the summer please. Defense sorted
 

0n0mat0p0eia

New member
For what its worth, Ballague on Revista said that if Barca gets Hummels, Amorebieta would then go to Dortmund, also Shalke were mentioned. There was also talk of Fulham in the EPL.

Amorebieta himself talked about the EPL
 
Y

Youngie

Guest
If Mats Hummels is even half as good as Thiago Silva then Barça are set (if Hummels is signed)
 

ZenI

Professor Balthazar
Amorebieta - Free in the summer. Would give the team experience, height and some bite (okay, hes prone to the odd red card)
Martinez - a young, powerful CB that would be in our team for years to come.

Getting Amorbieta free and Martinez for a reasonable fee would leave more than enough money for us to buy a world class 'Keeper (Ter Stegen).

Sadly, i suspect that we will buy Neymar and will tilt at windmills for Hummels - who we wont get - and end up with the same situation for next season.

It is simply not an option to not buy a CB for next season, and Hummels is not the answer to all of your prayers. Even Ibra would outrun Hummels, how on earth people fail to see a Chygrynskiy v2.0 is just unbelievable. We play with a very high defense only leaving 2 CB's and at times Busquets to defend, 1-2 quick counter players and Hummels is worth 'nada'.

Edit:

But don't get me wrong, if we didn't have Pique already and if Hummels was paired with a fast CB he would work wonders. He is the best playmaking CB out there, absolutely wonderful. But paired with Pique I fear it will not work as well. And also, Busquets drops deep to start our play from the back - how will this work out with Hummels?
 
Last edited:

khaled_a_d

Senior Member
I would like us to get Vertoghen actually, we need someone with pace who can defend and is also a goal threat

Actually Hummels is a goal threat too ,he is also very good passer and in moving forward
I think both are very good options
Tbh ,I gotta agree with DonAndres ,we need 2 new CBs ,I won't mind waiting for Neymar 1 more year to make it happen

It is simply not an option to not buy a CB for next season, and Hummels is not the answer to all of your prayers. Even Ibra would outrun Hummels, how on earth people fail to see a Chygrynskiy v2.0 is just unbelievable. We play with a very high defense only leaving 2 CB's and at times Busquets to defend, 1-2 quick counter players and Hummels is worth 'nada'.

Edit:

But don't get me wrong, if we didn't have Pique already and if Hummels was paired with a fast CB he would work wonders. He is the best playmaking CB out there, absolutely wonderful. But paired with Pique I fear it will not work as well. And also, Busquets drops deep to start our play from the back - how will this work out with Hummels?

I don't think Hummels is that slow at all tbh ,And he is way better player than Chygrynskiy
And tbh ,we might need to start thinking about putting Pique on the bench more ,as I said we need 2 CBs ,Hummels might be the one replacing Pique in the starting line up ,Pique hasn't beeh his former self for some while now ,and he need to feel there is a competition
I think Hummels might be worth the risk
 
F

Flavia

Guest
I'd now like 2 cbs. Inigo Martinez and Vertonghen. One to bench Pique, the other to rotate.
 
I'd now like 2 cbs. Inigo Martinez and Vertonghen. One to bench Pique, the other to rotate.

I'd also like 2 CBs; one to replace Puyol, and one to rotate and challenge Pique for the starting spot. I think Pique'll get his shit together if that happens.

I don't think Pique needs to be benched. He just needs some competition.
 

Home of Barca Fans

Top