Some of my EV criticism was over the top, but it's also true that the team was much better back then, had much more money, some legends still close to their prime (even is slightly past it), and so on.
-You say the team was better back then meanwhile you trashed the likes of Rakitic, Vidal, Roberto, Suarez and even Messi regularly. And I remember you constantly going on and on about how a good manager elevates his team. So if that team was so much better, then maybe Valverde wasn't so bad...?
-Yes, the team had more money, but there were guys like abidal and bartomeu in charge of that money. We never tried to build a balanced squad, the squad had glaring holes and Valverde would be blamed for all of it. Did Valverde even get a single signing he requested for?
-'Some legends still close to their primes'
Most of those players were in their thirties or close to it. You yourself used to berate several of them as finished players.
I don't want to make this about about Valverde, but I find it really odd how you vehemently defend Xavi for the same things you criticized Valverde for.