Xavi vs Iniesta

Xavi or Iniesta, who was better?


  • Total voters
    42

jamrock

Senior Member
Speaking of deco, his greatness doesn't get appreciated enough.

Definitely better than the likes of Gerard and lamps, obviously.

If he played for Portugal while they had Ronaldo, or choose Brazil, he would be up their in that group behind, the midfield generals, maybe even be amongst them.

He would probably be in that kroos, modric category, with a better international career.

What he did at Porto was legendary, and he was pivotal to Barca's CL success.

Ballon d'or runner up 2004.
2 CL.
6 league titles, 3 outside Portugal
 

Temptation

Well-known member
And before msn, we have messi, Henry
Messi, Villa.

You're point is irrelevant, we always had a goated front line.

Iniesta was great in the treble winning season.

A simple Google would have saved you from liking the post about shaky Barca in 12/13 though 😂 😂.

Shaky 15 point league win and CL SF 😂 😂.
Washed up Henry and Villa were definitely not Prime Neymar or Suarez level.


MSN was a comfortably better front 3 than anything Barca had before or after........


It didn't last long but MSN had great chemistry too. It's not just big names together.
 

Temptation

Well-known member
BTW, Pirlo>>Kroos.


Pirlo is right up there with Xavi, Iniesta and Modric.


Old Pirlo could barely move.....yet he dominated games with his technique and IQ.


Never forget when Pirlo had an injury in his right leg, he just casually ran the game only using his left foot. :lol:
 

jamrock

Senior Member
Washed up Henry and Villa were definitely not Prime Neymar or Suarez level.


MSN was a comfortably better front 3 than anything Barca had before or after........


It didn't last long but MSN had great chemistry too. It's not just big names together.

Nothing you can really say to save the point you tried to make.

We won big with those guys..

Dinho
eto'o
Villa
Henry
Saurez
Neymar
Messi.

We always had a goated front line, none of that takes away from the greatness out Xavi or Iniesta.

See Spain.....

Your attempts to try and down play Barcelona's players greatness is always easily batted away, but I respect that you keep trying.
 

Temptation

Well-known member
Iniesta is amazing but there are players that can do his job or function in a similar role.


Xavi is unique and absolutely irreplaceable. I'm yet to see 'the next Xavi'.


Don't rate him as a manager at all and think he's very immature on the touchline but as a player he was supreme.
 

Temptation

Well-known member
Nothing you can really say to save the point you tried to make.

We won big with those guys..

Dinho
eto'o
Villa
Henry
Saurez
Neymar
Messi.

We always had a goated front line, none of that takes away from the greatness out Xavi or Iniesta.

See Spain.....

Your attempts to try and down play Barcelona's players greatness is always easily batted away, but I respect that you keep trying.
Yeah I forgot Xavi was a Madridiot.

Silly me! Defending Los Blancos prick Xavi. :lol: :lol:
 

jamrock

Senior Member
Busquets dictated
Xavi controlled
Iniesta mesmerized
Messi destroyed.

The greatest youth system in the history of the world.

Legitimately the only thing that could stop those guys at their best, was a literal act of God.

Do you know how good you have to be, for God to have to step in with a volcano to slow your roll.

I will accept no diminishing of those 4 legacy by even a millimeter.
 

Porque

Senior Member
Iniesta is amazing but there are players that can do his job or function in a similar role.


Xavi is unique and absolutely irreplaceable. I'm yet to see 'the next Xavi'.


Don't rate him as a manager at all and think he's very immature on the touchline but as a player he was supreme.

Iniesta is better manager.
 

serghei

Senior Member
Washed up Henry and Villa were definitely not Prime Neymar or Suarez level.


MSN was a comfortably better front 3 than anything Barca had before or after........


It didn't last long but MSN had great chemistry too. It's not just big names together.

True, individually. But the thing is Villa and Pedro were far more likely to work hard off the ball, and this was essential for our pressing system.

With bigger egos up front, the team becomes an elite galactico team, and you lose on control and pressing. MSN Barca would have lost vs Pep's peak side probably 7 out of 10 matches or worse.
 

vegitot

Senior Member
BTW, Pirlo>>Kroos.


Pirlo is right up there with Xavi, Iniesta and Modric.


Old Pirlo could barely move.....yet he dominated games with his technique and IQ.


Never forget when Pirlo had an injury in his right leg, he just casually ran the game only using his left foot. :lol:
Pirlo had to hide behind so he could play. Kroos is much better even though he is a bastard.
 

vegitot

Senior Member
Remove Xavi from the Spain squad and they would have been 0/3 from 2008-2012.

Remove Iniesta and they would have atleast 1/3, most likely 2/3.

Silva and Fabregas could have replaced Iniesta in those teams, but no player could have done what Xavi did.
Lmao Silva or Fabregas could replace Iniesta. Fabregas was once Barca player, you can't fool me.

As great as Silva was, he had no business to replace Iniesta.

Remove Iniesta out of Spain from 2008-12, i'm sure they would not win anything. Same with Xavi.
 

Home of Barca Fans

Top