10 - Lionel Messi - v5

xxxxxx

Senior Member
Barca constantly have got the better of Real and Messi has been very good last two times against them. All time great in one.

Messi also does it againsy Atletico.

So it is not about destroying weak teams.

Nothing to do with being fickle. It is completely fair to expect more from Messi than today.

Why is Messi able to perform in La Liga?

You're acting like Messi hasn't performed in the Champions League. His goalscoring speaks for itself in the Champions League. He cannot put in a goat performance all the time, especially with that Barcelona team. He still needs support! Why can't you get that into your head?
 

serghei

Senior Member
Ronaldo has aged better. This is what age does to you. Makes you to have to work harder to stay at the top. And if you are not up for it, then let Ronaldo do it.

I always thought Messi is like Federer. But looking at Ronaldo and Federer well in their 30s, maybe I got it wrong.
 

ebc_99

Active member
There is no shame to admit that Ronaldo is the superior CL knockout player. In the past 5 seasons Messi scored 2 goals from the quarter finals onwards while Ronaldo scored 20. It's what it is and it's not only because Madrid have a better midfield either. Madrid were heavily outplayed many times by even Wolfsburg and Schalke in recent years but Ronaldo came up with braces and hattricks when needed and we Barca fans played it down as "rubbish opponents anyway".

Ronaldo scored from chances created by his team-mates, what did Barca create tonight for Messi? or last year or the year before. If all Messi had to do was finish chances we would never lose.
 

Luftstalag14

Culé de Celestial Empire
You're acting like Messi hasn't performed in the Champions League. His goalscoring speaks for itself in the Champions League. He cannot put in a goat performance all the time, especially with that Barcelona team. He still needs support! Why can't you get that into your head?

Of course Messi has been shouldering a lot of burden for the team and has bailed us out countless times. But it is very frustrating to say the least to see that he appeared disinterested and unmotivated in high-stake games like today's.
 

JamDav1982

Senior Member
Ronaldo scored from chances created by his team-mates, what did Barca create tonight for Messi? or last year or the year before. If all Messi had to do was finish chances we would never lose.

Ronaldo has scored all sorts of goals and been the most deadly player in the world on the break if teams played a high line like Roma tonight.

Messis team mates have given him a big enough platform to help beat Real and Atletico domestically but get dicked by Roma and other teams in CL.

For me it is not about the fact Messi didnt just go and decide the game it is that he showed no desire, ideas or effort to change it or even try to.

When the argument is that he is better than Ronaldo as he is the scorer, midfielder and creator then he should show it and at least make efforts to improve things. Which in CL he has not been doing.
 

pregra

Active member
The big difference for me is that Madrid has way more players who can go past opponents, giving Cronaldo space that Messi doesn’t get. Both their fullbacks, Modric, Isco, Bale, Asensio, heck even Vazquez. We have Dembele (who is still struggling) and Coutinho. That’s it.
 

Stoichkov1

New member
Ronaldo has scored all sorts of goals and been the most deadly player in the world on the break if teams played a high line like Roma tonight.

Messis team mates have given him a big enough platform to help beat Real and Atletico domestically but get dicked by Roma and other teams in CL.

For me it is not about the fact Messi didnt just go and decide the game it is that he showed no desire, ideas or effort to change it or even try to.

When the argument is that he is better than Ronaldo as he is the scorer, midfielder and creator then he should show it and at least make efforts to improve things. Which in CL he has not been doing.

Real Madrid also would never concede 3 goals against Roma.

Messi was shit but the whole team was shit.
 

BusiTheKing

Senior Member
Messi dragged this mediocre ass team to a league title while Ronaldo's "self management" was one of the main reasons for RM dropping out of the title race in january.

Just because the B d'Or is determined by CL performance only, doesn't mean that we have to descend into that mindset when evaluating the two.

Still a disappointing performance tonight by Messi.
 

Felipetonelo

New member
The big difference for me is that Madrid has way more players who can go past opponents, giving Cronaldo space that Messi doesn’t get. Both their fullbacks, Modric, Isco, Bale, Asensio, heck even Vazquez. We have Dembele (who is still struggling) and Coutinho. That’s it.

So true.
 

ebc_99

Active member
Ronaldo has scored all sorts of goals and been the most deadly player in the world on the break if teams played a high line like Roma tonight.

Messis team mates have given him a big enough platform to help beat Real and Atletico domestically but get dicked by Roma and other teams in CL.

For me it is not about the fact Messi didnt just go and decide the game it is that he showed no desire, ideas or effort to change it or even try to.

When the argument is that he is better than Ronaldo as he is the scorer, midfielder and creator then he should show it and at least make efforts to improve things. Which in CL he has not been doing.

Well that is the managers fault then, why else have a manager if he is not preparing the players for these types of occasions? Ronaldo is deadly because Real create opportunities for him, Barca don't do the same for Messi. What did Suarez do tonight or Iniesta, they should be helping him, its a team sport.
 

Pedro

La Masia
Messi almost scored late on, got past a crowd of players, ball fell to him, but scuffed his shot straight to the keeper from about 5 yards out
 

Ursegor

World Champion
Ronaldo scored from chances created by his team-mates, what did Barca create tonight for Messi? or last year or the year before. If all Messi had to do was finish chances we would never lose.

Before the pass comes the move, as Xavi once said. If Messi played for Madrid instead of Ronaldo they'd lose and people would blame rubbish Benzema scoring 5 goals all year and turtle Kroos making only sideway passes. If you actually watch Madrid they create "easy" chances through spamming crosses. Ronaldo lives off aerial balls, being at the right place at the right time for second balls and being quick on counter attacks. Messi doesn't have that scoring versatility, creating chances for Messi is a lot harder.
 

Felipetonelo

New member
Ronaldo has scored all sorts of goals and been the most deadly player in the world on the break if teams played a high line like Roma tonight.

Messis team mates have given him a big enough platform to help beat Real and Atletico domestically but get dicked by Roma and other teams in CL.

For me it is not about the fact Messi didnt just go and decide the game it is that he showed no desire, ideas or effort to change it or even try to.

When the argument is that he is better than Ronaldo as he is the scorer, midfielder and creator then he should show it and at least make efforts to improve things. Which in CL he has not been doing.

He can't create for himself because there's no space, he can't create for Suarez who just dives and points to the ref, he can't create for Roberto, for aged Iniesta. What kind of things he should do?
 

JamDav1982

Senior Member
Well that is the managers fault then, why else have a manager if he is not preparing the players for these types of occasions? Ronaldo is deadly because Real create opportunities for him, Barca don't do the same for Messi. What did Suarez do tonight or Iniesta, they should be helping him, its a team sport.

Suarez did as much for Iniesta as Messi did.

If the claim is Messi is the better all round player and midfielder, scorer and creater as opposed to Ronaldo then it is lame argument to go on about his team mates not providing for him.

Messi has the platform to perform better than Ronaldo in la liga most seasons. If he and team fail in CL against weaker or comprable sides that is on all of them including Messi and Messi.
 

Home of Barca Fans

Top