Tata deserves high marks for his first half season, even if Barca loses at AM Sunday.
His #1 job was to not screw up this fantastic team. Grade: A
Integrate Neymar: A. Easing him in was a huge success, I think you can make a strong argument that he is already the second best player on the team. I expect a huge second half from Neymar.
Man management: A. So many of the players are performing at a very high level now. The rotation policy is clearly superior to how this was managed by Tito or Pep. No one was overplayed in the first half, despite injuries at most positions. The competition for playing time has the first subs at CB, the two offensive midfield positions and the two wing forward spots playing so well that Tata has to exclude completely deserving players from his first 11. The two FB subs and Song have also played quite well, Pinto has been OK. Tata has not been been able to get Puyol to be younger, and Tello and Roberto have been beaten out for playing time, but these things are going to happen.
Results: If lose to AM: B+. Great in CL and Copa, 49 points and AM at home in the second half is hard to complain about in Liga. If Win at AM: A+.
His image, his marketing are not at Pep level, but Pep was second to none in those areas.