BBZ8800
Senior Member
Our main problem is not "number" or formation name is the way we play: TO SLOW with TO MANY TOUCHES.
We have 1000s of problems and a lot of different things in which we could improve.
But our formation against bigger teams is also one of them.
People often say that we are not as strong anymore because we don't run, press, play triangles etc...
But two things are certain:
1. Xavi, Messi and Iniesta are not as good as 5 years ago anymore
2. this is not 2008-2011 anymore, and no matter what some say, all teams (and especially top teams) have learned how to play against us.
We were the best team back then. We were the team who you have to look at, and against whom you need to find a special tactics.
If we assume that other teams are not coached by idiots, it is very easy to realize that if you play against a team who doesn't change anything in their tactics for years (that's us), after each new game/season you will find new things and tricks how to outplay and neutralize them.
Until 2008, they played 2-4 times against our new tactics/style.
Today, opponents have played 15-20 matches against us (and we haven't evolved much since then).
I will always repeat, even with Messi, Xavi and Iniesta in their prime, that team would have troubles today, in 2014'.
In those glory days, our style and tactics were somewhat new and fresh, and most of the opponents didn't know what to do. Most of them played extremely naive against us and they were trashed easily.
Today virtually anyone knows how to play against us.
Yes, we could run and press more. We could play better passes and try not to lose balls (to avoid counterattacks). We are not as motivated as back then, we don't have a faith in ourselves anymore, our players are past their prime, we play too slow. That is all true.
But imo, even with all these things mentioned above working at 100%, I think that we would have problems today against Real, Atletico, Bayern and Chelsea.
Or, in the best scenario, we would be at 50:50 chances.
1. they are all technically equally as good as our team
2. they are all physically stronger
3. they all have a formation/tactics to neutralize our outdated formation
But both in Rijkaard's and Pep's era, our team wasn't "only" 50:50 with top teams.
We were 60:40 favorites against any top team.
Football is changing and evolving all the time.
Our 433 is dead for me against top teams. I would welcome any other 442 or 451 for matches against top sides.
The current 433 will only be weaker and weaker each Season. Again, because we aren't evolving and other teams have learned how to neutralize our current, outdated formation.
A lot of our fans said that the body language from our players was poor again when we started losing against Real.
I will blame 433 again.
What if our players also already know that no matter what they'll try and do, that they just can't score enough Goals, and that they will always concede at least 2 Goals against any stronger opponent (with the current tactics)?
I have an impression that Messi and players think: "I don't have an idea what to do anymore. We tried everything for 1000 times in the last 3-5 years. If we play through the middle, we can't do anything. If we play through flanks, it is even worse. And yet, no matter what we do, we are always caught on 5-10 counterattacks or set pieces, and we always lose."
It seems like they gave up.
I will blame our outdated 433 for most of the problems.
Again, I would play 433 against 90% of midtable and bottom table teams.
But against stronger teams, it just brings loses and frustration.
1. Real just feels "better/stronger" than us in el classicos in the last 3-4 Seasons
2. we don't have any idea how to create anything against Atletico
3. Bayern, Chelsea, Psg, basically, we lose 75% of matches against stronger teams with our 433
The only "naive/rookie" teams which we can still trash and "mask" our problems are "naive" teams like Arsenal, Man. Utd, Roma, Ajax, Porto, Bayer Leverkusen and similar teams.
Who either don't play a bus against us, or who's bus isn't good enough to neutralize us.
Pep's 433, good bye (against stronger teams). Thanks for all the joys and everything.
It's time for something new.
Last edited: