Marquinhos

[Alarcón]

Yes he is

 

[linetty]

Slightly.

 

[Xavinho]

Whether he'd prove to be better or not, he'd still have to compete with Bartra for minutes, and there are no guarantees in football.

 

[Behrox]

Yes he is

No he isn't. Did he play against Real, Bayern, Atletico, etc. Nope he played in the Seria A (Ok credit here) and to a lesser extent in Ligue 1

 

[Alarcón]

No he isn't. Did he play against Real, Bayern, Atletico, etc. Nope he played in the Seria A (Ok credit here) and to a lesser extent in Ligue 1

Ryan Shawcross also played against Chelsea, United, City, Liverpool, Arsenal and Tottenham, does that mean he's better than Marquinhos?

 

[Behrox]

Ryan Shawcross also played against Chelsea, United, City, Liverpool, Arsenal and Tottenham, does that mean he's better than Marquinhos?

Yes . I should have phrased it better I meant played well against quality opposition and aren't you the one who always has something negative to say on Bartra's performance

 

[hulinat]

Bartra in La liga this season:

Appearances: 17(3)
Total tackles: 59
Total interceptions: 57
Total fouls: 18
Total clearances: 71
Total dribbled by other players: 15
Total shots blocked: 12
Rating: 7,39

Marquinhos in Ligue 1 this season

Appearances: 17(4)
Total tackles: 28
Total interceptions: 38
Total fouls: 12
Total clearances: 73
Total dribbled by other players: 5
Total shots blocked: 10
Rating: 7.02

Bartra>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Marquinhos

 

[DinhoR10]

Bartra plays better than him AND plays against much better opponents. The only thing marquinhos has on him is experience at RB and from seeing Bartra this season having to play CB/RB thanks to Alves/Poor tata tactics, I can say he'd probably be fine as a Defensive RB.

 

[Butaan4barca]

do look at the considerable difference in the "total dribbled by other players"

 

[Behrox]

do look at the considerable difference in the "total dribbled by other players"

One played against Di Maria, Ronaldo, Bale, Turan, Costa and co while the other was playing substitute in the French League. Its a considerable difference in quality of the opponent

 

[DinhoR10]

do look at the considerable difference in the "total dribbled by other players"

And what about the tackles or interceptions? No need to be selective.

and Edit: Bartra played against Bale and Di Maria, Thiago Silva and Kompany for all the fanboying they get would get owned by those too.

 

[CatalinR10]

bartra is baws

 

[khaled_a_d]

Bartra in La liga this season:

Appearances: 17(3)
Total tackles: 59
Total interceptions: 57
Total fouls: 18
Total clearances: 71
Total dribbled by other players: 15
Total shots blocked: 12
Rating: 7,39

Marquinhos in Ligue 1 this season

Appearances: 17(4)
Total tackles: 28
Total interceptions: 38
Total fouls: 12
Total clearances: 73
Total dribbled by other players: 5
Total shots blocked: 10
Rating: 7.02

Bartra>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Marquinhos

Yeah,stats

 

[Alarcón]

stats

 

[mackybagnack]

Bartra better or on the same level with Marquinhos? :tata1: Marcos was playing as starting CB for a top Serie A club and had clubs like us and PSG after him when he was 19 years old. what has Bartra done except doing a few good tackles against this or that low quality Spanish team ?