Crews
New member
That's debatable, all BM fans think all their players are better than ours, bar messi, so it's unclear
Everything is debatable when it comes to personal opinions.
Thomas Muller
- Thread starter Hamzah
- Start date
Everything is debatable when it comes to personal opinions.
serghei
Senior Member
That's debatable, all BM fans think all their players are better than ours, bar messi, so it's unclear
Nah, I'm sure they know Messi and Neymar are better than Muller. Even if they argue the other way.
why not? and our forwards are better but not ''considerably better''.
Crews
New member
It's not like Müller hasn't been the top scorer of the WC at a young age, almost twice. Proven to be a big game player with immense work-moral. His style is unorthodox, he exploits space in a manner never seen before and uses his intelligence for scoring and assisting. Neymar on the other hand is the flashy dribler little bit like Ribery but he doesn't have that work-moral though. I'd like to hear how someone can compare these two players objectively and come up with some stat based on universal truth of betterness that makes either one superior compared to other.
Trickykid
Active member
Care to elaborate on that? Good player, sure, but - as I see it - hardly someone who has actually reinvented the game as you claim.
Crews
New member
http://theraumdeuter.com/raumdeuter-meaning/
I might have been a bit misleading but I think that article summs up my message well enough. Ribery vs Neymar and Müller/Lewandowski (in a system that suits him ie Dortmund 2 years ago) vs Suarez is really a matter of opinion. The hype in the PL is unbelievable and inflates the prices and value trough the roof. Suarez was a great buy for you guys but the sheer price also creates surrealistic expectations that affects one's subconsciousness, in other words the Bale-case. Not going to bring up my opinions on Messi vs Robben since the latter has a god-like status among Barca fans and I would most likely get burned at the stake for blasphemy so in a nutshell I do not take any official stand on how good Messi is nor that is he the best player in the world, but rather honour your respectful opinions on the matter.
Edit: I can't make post that article as a hyperlink on my phone so if someone wants to read it they just have to copypaste it.
Last edited:
He's effective near goal in both scoring and assisting, but doesn't offer much in terms of buildup etc. He'd be a huge flop in Barcelona.
Crews
New member
You're just proving my point. The fact that he allegedly wouldn't fit in Barca doesn't mean he's worse than Neymar or Suarez and difference in style makes player to player comparison unreasonable at best.
He's definitely worse than Suarez. Suarez can do everything Muller does, plus he can also contribute in other areas. Muller is a team player - he need good team around him to be effective. Neymar is carrying whole Brazil offense on his back. Muller would never be able to do it for Germany. So yes, I'd rather have Neymar than Muller on a team.
Like I said few days ago, Muller is similar to Luis Enrique. Good effective universal player, midfield/forward hybrid, scoring a lot of important goals, but unable to be "alpha player" on his team.
DrPepper
New member
Nah, Müller might be the best player in world football at finding space. His intelligence and understanding of the game is his main asset, as his technique and physique isn't really that great. Doesn't need to be if he's always in the right position, though. Whether you prefer Neymar or him is just a matter of preference.
But prefering Robben ahead of Messi is just clear bias. No one outside Bayern or Holland would suggest that.
But prefering Robben ahead of Messi is just clear bias. No one outside Bayern or Holland would suggest that.
Crews
New member
Therefore I said with extreme clarity that I do not take an official stand on the subject.
Home of Barca Fans
