His productivity as a right back is absolutely ridiculous.
People forget his age. Dude's young af. He's way better than Marcelo and Alves were at his age. If he played for Barca or Real you guys would be fawning over him.
He'll only get better from here. Even his flaws like defensive game are clearly improving.
First of all, calma!
You are not talking to Liverpool haters, and as far as I am concerned I like Pool the most from EPL teams
Then, the argument that 'he won CL and PL' says little to nothing.
All the members of the team won those titles and all of them played under Klopp.
You may wanna counter that he was starter, that's fine. But there is nothing more to it.
If he is given sporting merit for the titles, it's only because he was a cog in Klopp's wheel like anybody else.
Then, the fact that Klopp defended his player in a press conference, says again nothing.
Yes, that's what Klopp always does and acts as a father to his players, and it's totally legit.
That doesn't mean that the point about his defensive weaknesses is not strong.
Then, 'he can only get better' is wishful thinking at its best.
IMO he has regressed the last couple of years. Trent 18-20 > Trent 20-22: I see the same ability on the ball, but worse work ethic for the team, and worse choices of passes/crosses that end up in many ball loses.
Finally,
Yes, he works for Klopp's system, and Klopp has built his system in such a way to augment the abilities of every of his footballers while hiding their weaknesses.
That's why when they play elsewhere, you see different things (look at Winaldum for instance)
But, that doesn't mean whoever (like me) criticized him doesn't have eyes to make observations.
There is an argument there that if you want to counter, you have to do something better than 'he is young, he will only get better'.
The argument is that he doesn't work defensively as much as he should have, and he wastes many balls notwithstanding his ability.