OK. Let me give you but one example, just to drive my point home:
There was one member here under the username of: "Heisenberg is cooking" Remember him? I think that everyone would agree that he was extremely negative the whole time. He was at his most active, when the team was not doing well. Once the team started doing better and better, it seems that he has gone awol. Why do you think that is?
By the way, I was not referring to Barcagirl in particular. I have said as much in some other of my posts, that some members in here do not really strike me as genuine Barca fans. It is not only that they are negative, I am very negative on some things as well. But it is their overall tone, their excessive praise for other clubs/leagues/players/managers etc etc etc. Things that you would not really expect from a Barcelona fan!
Moreover, after our 8th consecutive CL victory, after 50 games so far this season in which we have shown the biggest bottle to any club anywhere in Europe by far, after some of our rivals have been lucky with draws, ref decisions, play in easier leagues etc etc etc, you have some Barca fans (alleged or real) whose first comment is: "We are going to lose to Bayern again" or something in that vain.
Is it unreasonable, for me as a Barcelona fan, on a forum named Barcaforum (!) no less, to be surprised negatively by such statements? If you think that what I am saying is unreasonable then I am really sorry.